This is the only false coin that does the traditional effects that I own, so, therefore, forgive me for being unable to compare it to the others.
The 3 in 1 is inexpensive, realistic, and gives no reason to buy multiple coins. The bite marks are relatively realistic, and the quarter biting effect is awesome. My only complaint is actually in this area. Sometimes, when you "spit" the bitten piece back on, the quarter shakes a little, and the trick may be uncovered. (forgive me if that revealed anything)
I have yet to use this coin for any effect other than that, but I don't need to. Making it go into the bottle is simple (I'm certain), and the coin will do that well. Any other effect that the ad says it will do can be done.
Also, replacing the rubber band (can I say that), is relatively easy. I was able to fix mine (it had to go all of the way throught the washer to break), with only a little bit of fidgeting.
I must add, if I can say, that the lines on the coin are nearly invisible. Unless you're trying to see something, and you're close up, you won't notice. Except for maybe the sides, which still are barely noticable, you're audience will not be able to tell the difference between this and a normal quarter. Just be certain that you don't show that back for a long enough time that they know what is there. I got a state quarter, and you might as well. Still, as long as you don't let them gaze at it, they won't notice a different back.
This coin, for the value, is a must have. It is realistic, easy to use, and will serve you well. Even my minor quibbles are easily overlooked. Just go buy one.