I think Criss Angel gets the nod out of everyone listed. Laymen come to me all the time talking about how fake Blaine seems, but that Angel looks like the real deal. My dad started questioning me on Angel, but can't stand Blaine.
I think you are so wrong. Blaine is amazing and all his tricks look extremly real, while Angel's look like there are so many camera tricks. Not to mention Blaine is a cool guy and Angel is so lame.
Angel will levitate 5 feet off the ground - and everyone claps when he comes back down. While Blaine only levitates a foot or so - it's more believable - and people freak out.