I experimented by buying different brands of index cards. Surprisingly, I found the brand that Walgreens sells to be extremely easy to tear. Index cards from Staples were hard to tear. It possible to tear any brand, using the suggestions above, but some brands make it easier to perform. Once I found a brand (batch) I liked, I bought about five packs, which will last for hundreds of performances. I also cut these index cards in half to do Osterlind's perfected center tear. I hope this helps.