OK. You got a coin with the paint peeling. That deserves the loss of maybe one star, and would likely be corrected by the seller (definitely if the seller was Penguinmagic). But beyond that, you never mention anything about the trick itself: visual impact, difficulty of performance, angle issues,etc. The fact that you shotgun blasted this trick based solely on a cosmetic defect devalues the trustworthiness of your judgment, and makes your review unreliable.