The ultimate close-up tossed-out deck. https://t.co/mndGB..

> James Brown LIVE

Very Poor Presentation Report this review
Verified buyer Pro Privacy ON (login to see reviewer names) on December 30th, 2016
Only someone with no background or training in hypnosis would accept as original, new, or somehow "cutting edge" the explanations being given by this so-called authority, who actually has simply copied completely the ideas of others, and presented them poorly. James Brown has simply borrowed every single idea presented in this lecture from other English hypnotists (for the most part), including hypnosis without trance, the automatic imagination model, body magic tricks, and the idea that hypnosis is suggestion.

Every so often he quickly dropped the name of someone who actually thought of these concepts, but only in a way that he could later claim he gave credit, when in fact he should have clearly stated when others discovered years before this copy-cat lecture. He gave the lecture as if the ideas presented were his concepts, which is utter rubbish. And he presented them extraordinarily poorly and superficially, which I suspect was to get people to sign up for his "academy".

The idea that the standard hypnosis induction is only a ritual that excites the imagination of those being hypnotized has been discussed since the 1950s. That's not a James Brown discovery. The idea that hypnosis is suggestion has been repeatedly stated since the 1800's, as evidenced by Hippolyte Bernheim's book, published in 1880, entitled "Suggestive Therapeutics". The showman Kreskin built his reputation on the idea that hypnosis is only suggestion, beginning in the 1960's. And he clearly has no concept that many other approaches to hypnosis exist, not the least of which is that of Ericsson.

James Brown is trying to portray himself as some type of pioneer in hypnosis, when in fact he is simply taking the ideas of others (mainly in England), and presenting them poorly to magicians who are unaware of what's already been presented to the hypnosis community in far greater detail. He presentation was poor, he presented no evidence to back up anything he said from actual textbooks of hypnosis (and there are many great ones from the UK), or publications, and he basically wasted 170 minutes to say what he could have said in 30 minutes at most.

I gave him 2 stars because he did give a good explanation of a body magic trick involving a foot stuck to the floor because of a shift in the center of gravity. That explanation he did well.

Report this comment
graekeren
Nov 08th 2017 11:49am
I really have to comment on your review, I totally disagree. I think you've misunderstood the point of what James Brown is trying to say and who he is. You are right that he is borrowing the concepts of other hypnotists, namely Anthony Jacquin and James Tripp but he adds his unique flavour to them. Hardly any hypnotist can claim that he has invented anything. Hypnosis is pure suggestion. Clark Hull (1884-1952) demonstrated that everything that could be done with hypnosis can be done without hypnosis. So every hypnotist that claims that he does something out of the ordinary is wrong. Hypnosis is pure suggestion and that is what James Brown is trying to get across. I don't know of any other hypnotist that demonstrates that fact as well as JB and that is what makes him unique. No funny language, no talk of trance, no hypnosis but still all the hypnotic phenomena. Both Anthony Jacquin and James Tripp (and most others) holds on to the hypnotic frame, JB escapes it, and does it brilliantly.

Report this comment
cedthegeek
Apr 08th 2019 10:33am
As someone who is a student of James' in his POWA Academy. I can agree with graekeren! What makes James unique is stance and his performance style. Anyone who has seen me perform will further understand how I took James' approach and am able to things such as this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bl3Qnc3Cx8g&t=121s

Add a comment
Bestsellers
See all bestsellers



Act Builder beta



     Get To Know Us

     Shipping and Store Policies

     Need Help?

Home | About Penguin Magic | The Penguin Foundation

Mail orders: Penguin Magic, 3299 Monier Circle, Unit A, Rancho Cordova, CA 95742
Call us at 800-880-2592 | International Dial: +1 707-317-6733

© 2002-2016 Penguin Magic. All Rights Reserved.
We hope you found the magic tricks you were looking for!