@jokerspade5. no, it can't be done from a shuffled deck. I would say it is not something you could set up in front of a spectator. You would have to do a deck swap. That said, once the deck is in play, there is no reason the spectator would suspect the deck had an order to it. They make all the choices so there is no reason to suspect the deck. Even if you did a few tricks with a shuffled deck, did something else and then came back to a card trick with this trick, they would not suspect anything. I know I did not when I first saw this trick.