Magic Tricks

The Cartesian Q & A One-On-One. The premise, effect and scripting of the The Cartesian Q & A One-On-One version is very nice. The way the effect is framed is unlike anything I have read before on the Q & A. It makes sense, is theatrical and dramatic, and when presented by a skilled performer, will almost certainly create a memorable experience for the participant. The thinking here is great, and all aspects of the effect are explained thoroughly and in detail. This is something I look forward to using. It won't replace my approach to doing readings, but it is an
effect I can see myself using in informal environments, that may lead to a reading being booked.

Three items not mentioned in the description for The Cartesian Q & A are it involves math, requires the participant to use their phone, and requires the participant to perform a calculation on their phone. I think these are important details, and I wish they were included in
the description. That said, the use of math and the participant performing a calculation on their phone are well justified with the premise of and scripting for this effect.

There is also a version of The Cartesian Q & A explained for use with an audience. The same core method is used, but for for 4 or 5 people in front of an audience. Once again, the thinking here is great, however, I am less enthusiastic about this version as I do not see it being something I will use. Why? Well, in addition to the use of math, each participant's phone and a calculation they need to perform, the audience version also requires the performer to use two different mnemonic systems. If you have a great short term memory and enjoy using mnemonic systems, this might be right up your alley, but I don't see this as workable at all for me. There is just too much going on, too many pieces of information to keep in my short term memory that I would almost certainly get mixed up in the heat of performance. When I do Q & A, I like to be looking right at the information when I need it, not trying to remember it. Your mileage may vary.

Am I glad I bought it? I have mixed feelings. I love to learn, am a life-long student of the Q & A, and once something is on my potential buy list, I usually end up getting it. For me, I don't consider this book a must have.

Is this something I will use? The One-On-One version, yes I will most likely use it, but it won't replace my go to methods and effects. The audience version, no I will not use it.