I was a little worried when I got it, because the tie will hang a little lower from your neck than a real tie and I thought that people would notice that. But now I've performed it about 10 times and nobody has mentioned anything. Even when they talked to me after the show and saw it close up.

For me it only works on a black shirt because a white shirt won't hide the secret. That's why it got 4 stars and not 5.
And I hide the tie in another way than the instructions because I can not make it work properly following the instructions. Another reason to not giving it 5 stars.

With my way of doing it, it looks awesome because I have my hands on my jacket, where they can see them and never let go. I just spin (slowly) and the tie is there :-)